Table of Contents

Brief Analysis on IETF RFC 1925

RFC 1925, titled "The Twelve Networking Truths," is a humorous document published by the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) on April 1, 1996, as an April Fool's Day RFC. The author, Ross Callon, presents twelve fundamental "truths" about computer networking in a tongue-in-cheek manner, while also offering some real insights into the field. Here's an analysis of the twelve networking truths:

  1. "It Has To Work."

This truth highlights the primary goal of any networking technology or solution: it must be functional and reliable. While this statement is humorous in its simplicity, it serves as a reminder that network designers and engineers should prioritize functionality and reliability.

  1. "No Matter How Hard You Push And No Matter What The Priority, You Can't Increase The Speed Of Light."

This statement addresses the fundamental limits of physics in networking, specifically the speed of light as a constraint on latency. Despite advances in technology, some limitations cannot be overcome, and designers must work within those boundaries.

  1. "With Sufficient Thrust, Pigs Fly Just Fine. However, This Is Not Necessarily A Good Idea."

This truth cautions against forcing a solution that may not be appropriate or optimal for a given problem. Just because something can be done doesn't mean it should be done, especially if it leads to unintended consequences or complications.

  1. "Some Things In Life Can Never Be Fully Appreciated Nor Understood By Looking At Numbers In A Spreadsheet."

This truth emphasizes the importance of practical experience and real-world testing, rather than relying solely on theoretical models or calculations. Networking solutions must be evaluated in actual use cases to truly understand their effectiveness and suitability.

  1. "The Most Dangerous Thing In The Computing World Is A Programmer With A Screwdriver."

This statement humorously warns against the potential risks of crossing disciplinary boundaries without sufficient expertise. While interdisciplinary knowledge can be valuable, there are risks when individuals attempt tasks outside their domain of expertise.

  1. "The Only Truly Secure System Is One That Is Powered Off, Cast In A Block Of Concrete And Sealed In A Lead-Lined Room With Armed Guards - And Even Then I Have My Doubts."

This truth highlights the inherent challenges in ensuring absolute security in computer networks. No matter how secure a system may seem, there is always a possibility of vulnerabilities or threats. Security should be an ongoing concern and a process of continuous improvement.

  1. "The Easier You Make It To Do Something, The Harder You Make It To Undo."

This statement emphasizes the trade-offs between usability and reversibility. As network solutions become more user-friendly and automated, the potential for mistakes or unintended consequences may increase, and it may be more difficult to revert those actions.

  1. "It Is Always Possible To Trade Off Bandwidth, Latency, And Cost."

This truth acknowledges the fundamental trade-offs in network design, as increasing one attribute (e.g., bandwidth) may come at the expense of others (e.g., latency or cost). Designers must balance these trade-offs to achieve the desired performance and cost-effectiveness.

  1. "Perfection (In Design) Is Achieved Not When There Is Nothing More To Add, But Rather When There Is Nothing More To Take Away."

This statement, attributed to Antoine de Saint-Exupery, emphasizes the importance of simplicity and elegance in design. Overly complex solutions may be more prone to failure, harder to maintain, and more difficult to understand.

  1. "It's Always Cheaper And Faster To Just Do It Right The First Time."

This truth highlights the value of proper planning, design, and implementation to avoid costly mistakes and rework. Investing time and resources upfront to do things correctly can save time and money in the long run.

  1. "Every Old Idea Will Be Proposed Again With A Different Name And A Different Presentation, Regardless Of Whether It Works."

This truth suggests that ideas in networking often resurface in new forms, even if they have been tried and proven ineffective in the past. It's important to learn from historical experiences and not fall into the trap of repackaging and reusing old ideas without proper evaluation.

  1. "In Protocol Design, Perfection Has Been Reached Not When There Is Nothing Left To Add, But When There Is Nothing Left To Take Away."

Similar to truth 9, this statement emphasizes the importance of simplicity and elegance in protocol design. Creating efficient and effective protocols requires eliminating unnecessary components and complexities. This can lead to better performance, easier implementation, and improved maintainability.

In summary, although RFC 1925 is a humorous document, it contains insightful observations and advice for the networking community. These twelve "truths" remind designers and engineers to focus on functionality, simplicity, security, and the inherent trade-offs and limitations in network technology.

Created by
Orhan Ergun

Orhan Ergun, CCIE/CCDE Trainer, Author of Many Networking Books, Network Design Advisor, and Cisco Champion 2019/2020/2021

He created OrhanErgun.Net 10 years ago and has been serving the IT industry with his renowned and awarded training.

Wrote many books, mostly on Network Design, joined many IETF RFCs, gave Public talks at many Forums, and mentored thousands of his students.  

Today, with his carefully selected instructors, OrhanErgun.Net is providing IT courses to tens of thousands of IT engineers. 

View profile