What is Optimal Routing and Suboptimal Routing in Networking

This may be seen as very easy for some of you but let's make a philosophy a little bit, which means let's design around optimal routing.

Network engineers know that one of the tradeoffs in network design is Optimal Routing. We want our application traffic to follow Optimal Routing right?

Not exactly right. I will explain why it is not always right but let's understand what exactly we mean with "Optimal Routing".

Based on which parameter optimality we are looking for?

The answer to this question is IGP Metric. From the source of the traffic to the destination, between the network nodes, cumulative/total cost. It can be Layer 2 or Layer 3 protocol, we prefer the shortest path. The shortest path, most of the time is calculated based on "Bandwidth". Thus, overall which path provides more bandwidth, that path is considered the shortest path, thus Optimal Routing.

This is not necessarily always the case, for example, BGP uses the shortest AS-Path length, not the bandwidth for Inter-domain routing but OSPF, and IS-IS, for example, look at the total bandwidth for the cost calculation inside the domain/AS.

Some of you might think that other than the shortest IGP cost, maybe the lowest physical distance (mostly called fiber mile distance), or the cheapest monetary cost we might use for optimality purposes, you are right. You may have a valid business case for it and in fact, we have technical solutions to do that.

RSVP-TE and Segment Routing-based Traffic Engineering provides functionality for you to have different policies in the network.

As we understand that Optimal Routing is mostly considered as the shortest cumulative IGP cost between the source and the destination network nodes, let's talk about why we may not want to send the traffic through the path which provides optimality.

Fish Diagram/Topology

The above picture is famously called as "Fish Diagram/Topology"

The reason is; that it looks like a fish but for us, it is important to understand that with this very basic topology, we can understand why we may need traffic engineering.

If every interface between the routers has the same IGP Metric, between the source and the destination routers in the above topology, always the top path would be chosen due to the shortest cumulative/total IGP Metric.

The bottom path wouldn't be used at all if we would rely on IGP routing protocols for path selection.

If we would like to utilize the bottom path for some of our application traffic, we need more than IGP routing functionality. RSVP and Segment Routing provides traffic engineering capability but those are not the topics of this post.

When we start doing Traffic Engineering, we are in fact accepting to do "Sub Optimal Routing".

We send only some of our traffic over the shortest IGP cost (Remember our Optimal Routing Definition), and intentionally we send some other traffic over a longer IGP cost path which is the Sub Optimal Routing path.

By the way, the shortest IGP cost path doesn't have to be a monetary wise cheaper one, or it may not be the lowest delay path, etc.

You may have a satellite link with the GEO orbit, which comes with 500+ msec latency but you may have more bandwidth on that compared to another path.

Let me summarize.

  1. We use Optimal Routing to define the shortest IGP cost path.
  2. This path may not be the Optimal path as per your policy
  3. Optimal Routing may not be desired for every of your application or service traffic
  4. Technologies such as RSVP and Segment Routing are used for Traffic Engineering which intentionally violates the Optimal Routing Path
  5. We intentionally send some of our Application traffic over Sub Optimal Routing path, but that path satisfies the constrain of the applications overlay that path
  6. There is no one correct answer for all networking requirements!

If you liked this post and would like to see more, please let me know in the comment section below. Share your thoughts so I can continue to write similar ones.

Created by
Orhan Ergun

Orhan Ergun, CCIE/CCDE Trainer, Author of Many Networking Books, Network Design Advisor, and Cisco Champion 2019/2020/2021

He created OrhanErgun.Net 10 years ago and has been serving the IT industry with his renowned and awarded training.

Wrote many books, mostly on Network Design, joined many IETF RFCs, gave Public talks at many Forums, and mentored thousands of his students.  

Today, with his carefully selected instructors, OrhanErgun.Net is providing IT courses to tens of thousands of IT engineers. 

View profile

Daniel Lardeux
Daniel Lardeux Senior Network Consultant at Post Telecom

I passed the CCDE Practical exam and Orhan’s CCDE course was very important contributor to my success. I attended the CCDE course of Orhan Ergun in July and it was exactly what I needed, Orhan is taking the pain to break down the different technologies.

Roy Lexmond
Roy Lexmond Senior Network Designer at Routz CCDE #20150017 & CCIE R&S; #26557

After I attended Orhan Ergun’s CCDE course I passed the CCDE practical exam.I really enjoyed the course a lot ...

Nicholas Russo
Nicholas Russo Network Consulting Engineer (CCDE/CCIEx2), Cisc

I signed up for Orhan’s CCDE training. This training is very technically detailed and the use-cases, quizzes, scenarios, and mind maps are all great resources in the overall training program. Orhan teaches his students to think like a network designer ...

Slide Heading
Slide Heading Network Systems Engineer at Conscia A/S CCIE #42544 (SP) & CCDE #20160015

Orhan is forcing you to take off the implementation hat that most of us have been wearing for many years, instead he is providing a new fancy design hat, which makes you see and deal with the issues presented ...

Kim Pedersen
Kim Pedersen CCIE in RS and SP (#29189) CCDE#20170021

I’ve used Orhan’s self-paced CCDE training material. If you are interested in knowing how all the technologies go together in a coherent design i can highly recommend it.I also enjoyed the Quizzes which helped pick out my weak spots in selecting ...

Laurent Metzger
Laurent Metzger 3xCCIE/CCDE Senior Network Architect

Hi Orhan. I passed the CCDE exam on February 22. I read everything that you put on your Self Paced CCDE Training course and it was very helpful in my success. Thank you very much.

Martin J. Duggan
Martin J. Duggan Network Architect at AT&T;, Ciscopress Author CCDE #20160006 & CCIE#7942

I attended Orhan’s April 201610 days CCDE Bootcamp. I am CCDE now !

You can tell Orhan has a great deal of experience, it really comes through when he presents his design case studies and the CCDE Practical scenarios.

Muhammad Abubakar
Muhammad Abubakar Lead Network Architect – CCDE #20160016 2xCCIE #26693 2xJNCIE VCIX

Your excellent CCDE materials and amazing Bootcamp helped me tremendously through my learning journey.Also thank you very much for being available whenever I have a design question or a complex design topics. I can’t compare your design skills ...

Jennifer Pai
Jennifer Pai Network/Security Engineer at KNET Technology

Thanks Orhan very much for this course. It helped strengthen my “Network design mind”.

Ruslan Silyayev
Ruslan Silyayev Solution Architect at R.I.S.K Company

Training by Orhan is not a CCDE preperation training only. It will be useful for engineers which are dealing with design. You want to pass CCDE exam or learn network design, then don’t look at anywhere else!

Sameer Meher
Sameer Meher Solutions Architect at 23 Wards/Japan

Orhan Ergun’s CCDE course was really very good. CCDE Level Intelligence was delivered very well and with very useful case studies and the scenarios, I am thankful to Orhan for all his help!

Ken Young
Ken Young Senior Technical Architect Province of Nova Scotia, 2xCCIE #41597 | CCDE #20170047

If anyone wants to understand network design and architecture, also pass CCDE exam , I recommend you to attend Orhan’s online courses! I am a CCDE now but learning is a journey, we will be together in your other courses too Orhan!

Matt Cross
Matt Cross Technical Architect at Heartland – CCDE #2019::7

Orhan did an excellent job of filling in the gaps of knowledge that I had that took me to the finish line of the practical exam CCDE. The community of people that Orhan facilitates are both engaging and supportive of the journey to CCDE. Orhan ...

Shiling Ding
Shiling Ding Sentinel Technologies – CCDE #2019::12

Just passed the CCDE Practical exam! I attended Orhan Ergun’s CCDE training program , used Orhan’s Instructor Led and Self-Paced CCDE training and Online CCDE Practical Scenarios during my CCDE journey. Orhan’s CCDE In Depth book is an excellent summary ...

Abelardo Basurto
Abelardo Basurto Solutions Architect at Cisco Systems – CCDE 2018::6

Hi everyone, I’ve just passed the CCDE Exam. My Number is CCDE 2018::6 I attended to Online CCDE Bootcamp of Orhan. I want to thank Orhan not only for the great book and bootcamp, but also for his commitment, availability and willingness to assist the ...

Hady Mohamed Abdellah
Hady Mohamed Abdellah Network Architect Hamad International Airport Qatar – CCDE 2018::1

Hi guys, I’m so happy that I passed the exam. I’ve already got my number CCDE 2018::1. Thanks to Orhan for being the best CCDE instructor in the world. I highly recomend Orhan’s CCDE Training and In-Depth-CCDE ...

Bryan Bartik
Bryan Bartik Sr. Systems Engineer at CompuNet – CCDE 20170059

Hi Orhan I passed CCDE Practical exam on November 2017 ! I really enjoyed your materials and quizzes and use cases. They were definitely helpful in my preparation. Thanks a lot !

Giedrius Trapkauskas
Giedrius Trapkauskas Network Solutions Architect at Liberty Global – CCDE 20180004

I attended Orhan’s CCDE Training in Istanbul and it was very helpful in my preparation. I passed the exam recently and I want to say Thank you Orhan! For those who want to pass the CCDE exam, definitely start with ...

Alaa Issa
Alaa Issa Sr.Solutions Architect – CCDE#20180033 3xCCIE ( Collab|DC|Security )#27146

I registered to Orhan’s training in Feb 2017. From that time, I attended Orhan’s training several times. The depth of knowledge which Orhan has is amazing, and how to present such consistent knowledge to the ...

Mazin Ahsan Design Lead Engineer | Solutions Engineer | CCDE License # 20160030 | CCIE Licence # 23892

I passed the CCDE Practical Lab exam on November 17,2016 from supplications of elders and dedication from my Sensei Mr. Orhan Ergun I took different CCDE bootcamps in the past. Orhan has the most depth and expertise ...

Jeff Patterson CCDE# 2018::11

Hi Orhan I wanted to pass along my appreciation for the outstanding training material. I used the online CCDE training provided by Orhan as well as the In-Depth-CCDE book and passed the exam in February 2018. Thank you Orhan!

Mehdi Sfar
Mehdi Sfar Network and Security Architect / CCDE #20210003 | CCIE R&S; #51583

I signed up for Orhan’s CCDE Self paced Course. This course, along with the CCDE In Depth book, helped me for my CCDE Practical as well as Written exams. It pushed me to ask the "WHY" questions and allowed ...

Related courses

Cisco CCDE v3 Training

71:39:34 Hours
225 Lectures
Expert

$995

Network Design Fundamentals Course

02:28:37 Hours
17 Lectures
Beginner

$50

Cisco CCIE Service Provider Training

108:43:00 Hours
258 Lectures
Expert

$995